- Description
-
- Creator(s)
- (?) Thomas Girtin (1775-1802)
- Title
-
- A Lake Scene with Cattle, Said to Be in Harewood Park
- Date
- 1798 - 1799
- Medium and Support
- Graphite and watercolour on paper
- Dimensions
- 12 × 24.7 cm, 4 ¾ × 9 ¾ in
- Object Type
- On-the-spot Colour Sketch
- Subject Terms
- Lake Scenery; The Landscape Park; Yorkshire View
-
- Collection
- Catalogue Number
- TG1545
- Description Source(s)
- Paul Mellon Centre Photographic Archive
Place depicted
Revisions & Feedback
The website will be updated from time to time and, when changes are made, a PDF of the previous version of each page will be archived here for consultation and citation.
Please help us to improve this catalogue
If you have information, a correction or any other suggestions to improve this catalogue, please contact us.
About this Work
This is one of a pair of lake, or possibly river, scenes that are said to depict a view in Harewood Park in Yorkshire, the seat of Girtin’s patron Edward Lascelles (1764–1814) (see figure 1). The artist’s large-scale distant views of Harewood House (TG1547 and TG1548) no doubt required him to make studies in the park, but there is nothing in either of these scenes to suggest that they depict the banks of the lake that Lancelot ‘Capability’ Brown (1716–83) created at the heart of the estate after 1772. It may be that the drawings were identified as showing a view at Harewood on the basis of an old inscription, but this has not been recorded, and in any case the only images I have found that show the banks from the same level do not include the hills seen here. Indeed, I would go further to suggest that the association of this scene with Harewood reflects a overemphasis on the importance of the Lascelles connection in general. Girtin’s stay at Harewood in 1800 is documented and there is strong circumstantial evidence for an extended visit in 1799, but that does not warrant the speculative identification of every park scene of roughly the right date as belonging to this house, as has occurred with A Circular Temple (TG1544).
Unfortunately, the two sketches are known only from black and white photographs, and I am therefore in a poor position to determine their precise status; are they sketches coloured on the spot – indeed, are they by Girtin? Features such as the clumsy depiction of the cattle and the fact that the three swans lack reflections in the water may suggest the work of an amateur follower, but I suspect that the weaknesses in the depiction of the trees may be a consequence of their fading. A final judgement on the drawings must be deferred until better images can be procured.
A similar park scene (see figure 2), again depicted across a broad panoramic format (slightly larger, but in the same 1:2 proportion), poses a similar challenge and this is likewise compounded by its faded state. The sky has disappeared entirely whilst the greens of the foliage and the grass have been reduced to a dull range of earth colours so that the whole appears as a flattened and undifferentiated mass. The rough textured paper, the economical use of washes, and the broad format may indeed point to Girtin’s authorship, but even accounting for the work’s poor state, this would be no more than a very perfunctory effort and on balance I suspect that it is not by the artist.
(?) 1801
Harewood House, from the South West
TG1547
(?) 1801
Harewood House, from the South East
TG1548
1799 - 1800
A Circular Temple, Said to Be in Harewood Park
TG1544